A letter to the editor
in the National Catholic Reporter,
14 September 2001

The Vatican's Chador

By Eileen M. DiFranco

Why must Mrs. George Bush, and her daughters, and any woman cover her body with a black dress and wear a mantilla on her head in order to have an audience with the Pope?  This reveals the main reason why women cannot be priests.  A woman’s body is so offensive to these celibate men that she must cover herself completely in black, as if in mourning for her female body.  Covering her head denotes her complete inferiority; such dress is the Vatican version of the chador.  

However, such strictures levied solely against women also hint of something else.  The covering of a woman’s body in the presence of the pope indicates that he must see her as an object, rather than as a person with hair, breasts and legs.  She must be neutered as much as possible in order to come into his presence.  In this way, he can distance himself from any acknowledgement of women; he can maintain the fantasy that women are “the other”, against whom every true celibate must protect himself.  An “object” regarded as “the other” can never be imagined as an equal, but only as a near occasion of sin, who must be at all costs kept out of priestly thoughts, away from priestly bodies, and off priestly altars. Why else would there be a need for the Vatican chador?